So, what does this mean in practice? Whilst a hot topic, currently most common law jurisdictions, including the Cayman Islands and we understand, Hong Kong, adopts the English “rule in Gibbs” where, put simply, a debt is treated as discharged only if compromised within the law of the jurisdiction governing the debt (with the exception that it is binding on those who submit to the jurisdiction where a scheme is being promulgated).

We have seen several schemes promulgated in various jurisdictions, including Cayman, BVI and Bermuda, which compromise New York law governed bonds. To satisfy a court that the scheme would be substantially effective in New York and binding not only on those creditors who had submitted to the jurisdiction but those who had not, often companies will seek recognition of the scheme by way of a Chapter 15 proceeding.

In a recent case in the US, a Chinese real estate developer, Sunac China Holdings Ltd (whose home jurisdiction is the Cayman Islands), has successfully obtained such Chapter 15 recognition of its Hong Kong scheme as a main proceeding. Recognition must be as a main proceeding (where the company has its centre of main interests “COMI”) or a non-main proceeding (where there is an establishment). Chapter 15 does not define COMI but there is a rebuttable presumption that the COMI is in the place of incorporation.

The New York bankruptcy judge in this case was satisfied that the centre of main interests is in Hong Kong and not in the PRC. Factors considered included the place where the company was head-quartered, the listing in Hong Kong, Hong Kong being the place of the company’s financial and restructuring activities, (including meetings) and the base of its historic operational activities. Whilst each case will depend on its own facts, and restructuring and other activities may be undertaken in the home jurisdiction or elsewhere, this case is a useful indicator as to how the US court will treat a Hong Kong scheme of arrangement of an offshore company with substantial assets in mainland China.

For more information in respect of Cayman, BVI or Bermuda advice, please contact any of the below or your usual Appleby contact.

Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
27 Sep 2022

Similar but Different

While the basic features of the trust remain, there are some notable differences in how trusts can b...

28 Apr 2022

Assignment, novation or sub-participation of loans             

Transfers of loan portfolios between lending institutions have always been commonplace in the financ...

12 Mar 2021

Material adverse change clauses in light of the Covid-19 pandemic

Experts from each of our key global offices provide jurisdiction specific advice and answer question...

8 Mar 2021

Appleby Celebrates International Women’s Day

International Women’s Day is celebrated annually in support of gender equality and equal participa...

14 Dec 2020

Economic Substance update Q4 2020

Economic Substance update Q4 2020

21 Sep 2020

The role of Private Equity in economic recovery from Covid-19

Against this gloomy backdrop, we expect private equity firms and their investors to play a key role ...

21 Aug 2020

Investment Funds and ESG Investing – the Appleby perspective

In this article, we examine these trends from the perspective of our Appleby offices around the worl...