The practice statement issued this week seeks to clarify the circumstances in which a wrongful trading claim may be brought against directors under Jersey law and emphasises certain matters by way of reassurance to directors, such as:

  • a wrongful trading claim can only be brought against a director if the company enters a formal insolvency process; and
  • for a claim to be successful, a director must know (or be reckless on the facts known to him or her) that the company no longer has a reasonable prospect of survival and there may be a wide spectrum of legitimate views as to what constitutes a “reasonable prospect”.  It may be that the Viscount or liquidator may only wish to pursue a clear claim, as there will be a significant evidential burden for them to overcome.

Directors are reminded that an order cannot be made against a director if they took reasonable steps to minimise losses to creditors and guidance is offered in the statement as to how directors may be able to demonstrate having taken such reasonable steps. Prudent financial and cash flow management are key during this time.  The practice note emphasises that it is not necessary to prove that losses to creditors were in fact minimised, rather that reasonable steps to this end were taken.

The practice statement offers practical guidance as to possible steps that could be taken that may go some way to defeat a wrongful trading claim should this be advanced at a later stage. What will be deemed to be reasonable in the circumstances will be very fact specific and the statement acknowledges that with the truly unprecedented circumstances that COVID-19 presents, there may simply be too many different views and approaches to say with any certainty that the directors did not take reasonable steps. This will offer some comfort to concerned directors at this time.

Type

Insight

Locations

Jersey

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
28 May 2020 |

Has Covid-19 flattened the fund finance curve?

Leading into the first quarter of 2020, the preceding 12 months saw a rapid increase in the demand o...

Contributors: Paul Worsnop
7 May 2020 |

An overview of Jersey’s commercial real estate market during the current crisis – A virtual discussion

Appleby’s property team recently hosted a well attended videoconferencing session with a number of...

29 Apr 2020 |

Working (Remotely) 9 to 5 (-ish)

In the past few weeks, more employees than ever before have been forced to work remotely, whether fr...

23 Apr 2020 |

COVID-19 – Signing of Wills in Jersey

Jersey law is not alone in having strict rules regarding the execution of wills. Except in the case ...

16 Apr 2020 |

COVID-19 – Commercial property guidance in Jersey

The Minister for Economic Development, Tourism, Sport and Culture has published Guidance relating, p...

15 Apr 2020 |

COVID-19: Temporary amendment of residential tenancy legislation in Jersey

As part of a raft of new legislation to address the far-reaching impact on society of the COVID-19 o...

6 Apr 2020 |

Wrongful Trading: Legal position in Jersey

During these uncertain times, business resilience and continuity is at the forefront and directors o...

Contributors: Mark Brady, Gemma Whale
2 Apr 2020 |

Jersey cash box structures: a fast route to funding

It is no surprise, as a result of the wider economic unpredictability arising from COVID-19, that li...

13 Mar 2020 |

Appleby contributes five chapters to Global Legal Insights – Fund Finance 2020

Appleby provided five chapters to the Global Legal Insights - Fund Finance 2020 Guide. The publicati...

5 Mar 2020 |

Jersey: a thriving hub for Energy & Natural Resources investment in Africa

Jersey’s role as a conduit for investment in energy and natural resources projects on the African ...

Contributors: Lebogang Maimane