The practice statement issued this week seeks to clarify the circumstances in which a wrongful trading claim may be brought against directors under Jersey law and emphasises certain matters by way of reassurance to directors, such as:

  • a wrongful trading claim can only be brought against a director if the company enters a formal insolvency process; and
  • for a claim to be successful, a director must know (or be reckless on the facts known to him or her) that the company no longer has a reasonable prospect of survival and there may be a wide spectrum of legitimate views as to what constitutes a “reasonable prospect”.  It may be that the Viscount or liquidator may only wish to pursue a clear claim, as there will be a significant evidential burden for them to overcome.

Directors are reminded that an order cannot be made against a director if they took reasonable steps to minimise losses to creditors and guidance is offered in the statement as to how directors may be able to demonstrate having taken such reasonable steps. Prudent financial and cash flow management are key during this time.  The practice note emphasises that it is not necessary to prove that losses to creditors were in fact minimised, rather that reasonable steps to this end were taken.

The practice statement offers practical guidance as to possible steps that could be taken that may go some way to defeat a wrongful trading claim should this be advanced at a later stage. What will be deemed to be reasonable in the circumstances will be very fact specific and the statement acknowledges that with the truly unprecedented circumstances that COVID-19 presents, there may simply be too many different views and approaches to say with any certainty that the directors did not take reasonable steps. This will offer some comfort to concerned directors at this time.

Type

Insight

Locations

Jersey

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
2 Sep 2021 |

Duties of Trustees

The relationship of trustees to beneficiaries is viewed as fiduciary, meaning there are certain equi...

18 Aug 2021 |

Beneficial Owners and Controllers (BOC)

The aim of BOC is to drill-down to the identification of persons who are the beneficial owners and c...

30 Jul 2021 |

Fighting international fraud

First published in New Law Journal, July 2021. Appleby partners Anthony William and Jared Dann an...

Contributors: Jared Dann, Claire Corkish
27 Jul 2021 |

Fund Finance Update – Will Jersey’s new sustainable investment disclosure requirements aid ESG financing?

This article provides an overview of ESG, the hot topic of 2020 that is carrying on full steam throu...

Contributors: Daniel Healy
22 Jul 2021 |

Listing Variable Funding Notes (VFNs) on The International Stock Exchange

This article provides a summary of Appleby listing agent services in the Channel Islands, and also o...

1 Jul 2021 |

Saunders v Vautier where the beneficial class is not closed - the debate goes on...

The rule in Saunders v Vautier is familiar territory for trust lawyers.  In the modern world it is ...

17 Jun 2021 |

Solvency Statements under Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 - Is it time to go paperless?

In April of this year, the Royal Court of Jersey considered the practicalities around the making of ...

Contributors: Kevin McQuillan
11 Jun 2021 |

“Offshore intelligence – Funds in demand” Appleby Podcast

We have recently produced a podcast focused on the Funds industry entitled “Offshore Intelligence ...

2 Jun 2021 |

Why use Jersey entities in restructurings?

As the extension of various forbearance measures and fiscal support packages continues in response t...

Contributors: Gemma Whale, Andrew Weaver
28 May 2021 |

Further updates to the JFSC’s AML Handbook

On 31 May 2021, the handbook for the prevention and detection of money laundering and the financing ...

Contributors: Gemma Whale