The Cayman Islands Court of Appeal (CICA) has now, for the first time, considered and set out the principles that should be applied in the event a petition is withdrawn, where the opposing company is left with thrown away costs. The judgment also provides a reminder of the importance of complying with procedural deadlines for key evidence and what may be taken into account in the ruling of the judge at first instance.

Summary

The CICA held that save under exceptional circumstances (which were absent in this case) a party which claims a debt that may be disputed bears the costs risk of pursuing such debt by way of statutory demand and winding up petition without first ensuring that any disputes are resolved. In this case, evidence that the petitioner had not known of the dispute before petitioning had been served out of time and only came to the judge’s mind by a procedural irregularity; it should not have influenced his ruling that the Petitioner did not have to pay the Debtor’s costs in defending the Petition.

Background to the case

KBC Investments V Limited (the Petitioner) was the assignee of a redemption debt of $1,068,530.31 (the Debt) owed by Aramid Entertainment Fund Limited (the Debtor), a company incorporated in the Cayman Islands carrying on business as a mutual fund. The Debtor had withheld paying the Debt because of proceedings it had initiated in New York (the New York Proceedings). However, the New York Proceedings failed at first instance and on appeal and so the Petitioner issued a statutory demand for the Debt.

The Debtor sought to argue that a further appeal and motion for re-argument was pending in the New York Proceedings but the Petitioner contended that the proceedings were finally resolved and issued a winding up petition on 10 July 2013 (the Petition) prior to the resolution of these issues. On the same day, but following service of the Petition, the Debtor commenced further proceedings in the State Court of New York against the Petitioner and others, seeking an amount in excess of the Debt (the Further Proceedings).

Read More

Type

Insight

Locations

Cayman Islands

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
27 Sep 2022

Similar but Different

While the basic features of the trust remain, there are some notable differences in how trusts can b...

30 Aug 2022

The Cayman Islands restructuring officer regime comes into force on 31 August 2022

These new proceedings will significantly enhance the Cayman Islands restructuring regime.

4 Aug 2022

Norwich Pharmacal orders: the right medicine for third party disclosure of information and documents in the Cayman Islands

A Norwich Pharmacal order (NPO) is a disclosure order available in the Cayman Islands to compel a th...

Contributors: Susan Fallan
1 Jun 2022

The 2022 Cayman Islands Real Estate Guide

The Real Estate 2022 guide provides the latest legal information on the impact of disruptive technol...

Contributors: Norman Klein
28 Apr 2022

Restructuring the offshore debt of Chinese Real Estate Developers

This article sets out how the current regimes in the Cayman Islands and the BVI can assist with rest...

Contributors: Crystal Au-Yeung
28 Apr 2022

Assignment, novation or sub-participation of loans             

Transfers of loan portfolios between lending institutions have always been commonplace in the financ...

26 Jan 2022

Appleby contributes four chapters to Global Legal Insights – Fund Finance 2022: Cayman Islands

2021 has been an incredibly impressive year for the global subscription credit and fund finance mark...

Contributors: Georgina Pullinger
27 Oct 2021

We hope this registers! A summary of Cayman corporate and partnership registers in a finance transaction.

Because we know that it can be a little befuddling, Appleby has set out a guide to the various Cayma...

7 Oct 2021

Regulatory Round-Up: Cayman Islands Q3 2021

Appleby Cayman’s Our latest Regulatory updates for the Cayman Islands up to Q3 2021.

13 Sep 2021

Loans & Secured Financing in the Cayman Islands 2021

First published in Getting the Deal Through 2021. This practice guide provides topical analysis of L...

Contributors: Alexandra Simpson