In common with many jurisdictions which have their origins in English law, Cayman has a statutory demand process by which a debt which has been formally demanded and which remains unpaid after a specified period leads to a non-paying company being deemed to be insolvent. If such a debt is undisputed, a petitioning creditor has a prima facie entitlement to an order winding up the company. However, the making of a winding up order is discretionary and a court may refuse to make the winding up order where there are “exceptional circumstances”.

By a petition dated 15 May 2020 (Petition), petitioning creditors (Petitioners) sought the winding up of Obelisk Capital Management Limited (Company) on the basis of its deemed insolvency following its failure to pay a statutory demand which had been served on 6 February 2020. In addition, the Petitioners sought the winding up of the Company on the just and equitable basis to investigate potential wrongdoing by the Company.  The Company responded by claiming that it was temporarily unable to pay the debt due to specific operational challenges which it faced as a result of the measures to combat COVID-19 introduced in a number of countries in which it operated. The Company argued that the service of the statutory demand and the petition were opportunistic and that COVID-19 constituted “exceptional circumstances” which meant that the Court should not make the winding up order.

The Court recognised the severe impact of COVID-19 and was sympathetic to the challenges faced by companies at this time. However, the Petitioners were able to show that the Company’s non-payment pre-dated the measures which had been introduced to address COVID-19. The Petitioners were, therefore, able to successfully argue that, in this case, COVID-19 did not constitute an “exceptional circumstance” and the Court made the winding up order.

The approach of the Court highlights the need for petitioning creditors to consider COVID-19 in any petition made at this time. Petitioning creditors need to proactively address COVID-19 and put forward evidence and argument which demonstrate why the current situation, which is clearly capable of causing massive operational and liquidity challenges for enterprises around the globe, does not constitute “exceptional circumstances” for the specific company. Conversely, companies responding to petitions need to closely tie the wider situation to their specific position if they are to successfully rely on COVID-19.

Appleby acted for the successful Petitioners in the above matter.

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More News
17 Nov 2020 | News

Appleby Cayman ranked in six categories in Legal 500

Appleby’s Caribbean offices in Bermuda, the British Virgin Islands and the Cayman Islands achieved...

12 Nov 2020 | News

Appleby lawyer named Private Client Lawyer of the Year

Appleby partner Carlos de Serpa Pimentel has been named Private Client ‘Lawyer of the Year’ in t...

5 Nov 2020 | News

Appleby Sponsors FFA Virtual Global Symposium

Appleby is proud to be a platinum sponsor of the Global Fund Finance Association (FFA) Symposium for...

Contributors: Fiona Chan
30 Oct 2020 | News

Offshore Business Update

This is an update for our clients on how the authorities in our core jurisdictions are responding to...

21 Oct 2020 | News

Safe Haven Found: The Cayman Islands introduces Global Citizen programme for digital nomads

On 16 October 2020, the Cayman Government gazetted regulations bringing into effect its Global Citiz...

Contributors: Esmond Brown
14 Oct 2020 | News

Sally Penrose and Jennifer Parsons speak on Regulatory webinar panel to New York State Bar Association members

The New York State Bar Association is hosting a virtual webinar entitled ‘Bermuda and Cayman Islan...

Contributors: Jennifer Parsons
6 Oct 2020 | News

The Cayman Islands removed from the EU’s blacklist

Appleby is pleased to advise that the Council of the European Union confirmed on 6 October 2020 that...

25 Sep 2020 | News

Appleby advises Chi Kan Holdings Limited on its HKD 130 million listing on the Main Board of the Hong Kong Stock Exchange

Appleby acted as Cayman counsel to Chi Kan Holdings Limited in relation to its listing on the Main B...

Contributors: Minnie Choi
23 Sep 2020 | News

Appleby shortlisted ‘Offshore Firm of the Year’ by The Lawyer

Leading offshore firm Appleby has been shortlisted in The Lawyer Awards 2020, ‘Offshore Firm of th...