Introduction

The recent decision in Re Harbinger Class PE Holdings (Cayman) Ltd confirms that the traditional “impossibility” test for loss of substratum will be applied in the context of a Cayman Islands company which is not an open-ended mutual fund. The decision appears, at first glance, to depart from earlier Cayman Islands authorities which deal with the question of what loss of substratum entails in the context of an open-ended mutual fund. Uncertainty remains, however, about the test for loss of substratum of a Cayman Islands open-ended fund, and this decision could be a step toward the traditional test for loss of substratum also being applied in that context.

The Proceedings

On 14 May 2015, a petition was presented by “NYROY/RBC Acct# 1583 pledged to Royal Bank of Canada” (the Petitioner) for the winding up of Harbinger Class PE Holdings (Cayman) Ltd (the Company) and the appointment of official liquidators. The Petitioner was a contributory of the Company, holding a 0.2% interest. The winding up was sought pursuant to section 92(e) of the Companies Law (2013 Revision) on the ground that it was “just and equitable” to wind up the Company as there had been a loss of substratum.

The Company was incorporated on 16 December 2008 as a subsidiary of Harbinger Capital Partners Offshore Fund 1 Ltd (the Offshore Fund). The Offshore Fund had been incorporated in the Cayman Islands in 2001 and operated as a feeder fund to Harbinger Capital Partners Masters Fund 1 Limited (the Master Fund). In 2008, the Offshore Fund was faced with substantial redemption requests from its investors which it, and in turn the Master Fund, lacked the liquidity to meet; the Company was therefore formed in order to restructure the illiquid investments which were valued at US$2.4 billion. The Master Fund issued a new class of shares, Class PE Shares, to which it allocated certain private equity-type and other illiquid investments called the “Private Portfolio”. The Class PE Shares were issued by the Master Fund to the Offshore Fund and were ultimately contributed to the Company; participating shares in the Company were then issued to redeeming shareholders in the Offshore Fund as partial in-kind redemption proceeds.

Read More

Type

Insight

Locations

Cayman Islands

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
4 Dec 2019 |

Revised Draft Guidance on Economic Substance in the Cayman Islands

The Cayman Islands continue to meet and exceed international compliance standards in a proactive and...

28 Nov 2019 |

Cayman Islands Funds update

This article provides details on the recent changes to the Cayman Islands Securities Investment Busi...

22 Oct 2019 |

Show Me the Money: Identification and Preservation of Assets in the Cayman Islands

The Cayman Islands has long had a developed arbitration framework providing for the recognition and ...

Contributors: Mehreen Siddiqui
21 Oct 2019 |

Cayman Regulatory Newsletter Q4 2019

Appleby Cayman is pleased to introduce our new Regulatory Newsletter. The first edition of this quar...

17 Oct 2019 |

Hot Topics

The Cayman Islands’ Data Protection Law, 2017 (DPL) came into force on 30 September 2019. Cayman e...

17 Oct 2019 |

Economic Substance

The Cayman Islands’ International Tax Co-operation (Economic Substance) Law, 2018 (ES Law) and The...

20 Sep 2019 |

How fund managers should prepare for the Cayman Islands Data Protection Law

The Cayman Islands Data Protection Law, 2017 (DPL) comes into force on 30 September 2019 and will re...

18 Sep 2019 |

When will foreign court - appointed receivers be recognized?

When will foreign court - appointed receivers be recognized?

18 Sep 2019 |

Offshore listing Vehicles to benefit from the Shanghai - London stock connect

Offshore listing Vehicles to benefit from the Shanghai - London stock connect

Contributors: Huiyan Liew
18 Sep 2019 |

Update: Economic Substance Requirements in Bermuda, the British Virgin Islands and the Cayman Islands

Economic substance requirements in Bermuda, the British Virgin Islands and the Cayman Islands

Contributors: Shana Simmonds