The Grand Court clarifies the ordinary rule for damages in temporary deprivation of property cases

Published: 27 Feb 2024
Type: Insight

The Grand Court of the Cayman Islands in Fortunate Drift Limited v Canterbury Securities, Ltd (FSD 227 of 2018) has provided helpful guidance on (i) the measure of damages ordinarily applicable in temporary deprivation of property cases; and (ii) the circumstances in which the ordinary rule may be displaced.


Background

The dispute concerned shares in Yangtze River Development Ltd (YRIV), a PRC based company listed on the NASDAQ. YRIV achieved NASDAQ listing in December 2015 through a “reverse merger” process, which became popular after the global financial crisis of 2008. The process involves a private company acquiring an existing, but often defunct, U.S. public company that still carries a symbol on a U.S. stock exchange. This enables the private company quickly to begin trading in the U.S. with the gravitas of a listed company, without having to go through the rigors of an IPO.

In the case, the key parties were Fortunate Drift Limited (FDL) and Canterbury Securities, Ltd (CSL). The sole asset of FDL, a BVI company, was said to be its shares in YRIV. CSL, a Cayman Islands securities investment company, provided brokerage services to FDL pursuant to a Brokerage Contract. FDL deposited 6 million of its YRIV shares with CSL for trading purposes.

In order to obtain finance, FDL entered into a Stock Purchase Agreement (SPA) with PFS Management Limited (PFS) in which PFS bought a certain number of YRIV shares from FDL for US$10 million. The SPA contained a put option allowing PFS to sell the shares back to FDL at a prescribed price. FDL was required to secure its obligations under the put option by leaving a sufficient amount of YRIV shares with CSL.

FDL and CSL became embroiled in a dispute which resulted in FDL terminating the Brokerage Contract and demanding the return of its YRIV shares held by CSL.  CSL refused to return any shares and subsequently sold a proportion of the YRIV shares purportedly to preserve the value of the security, should PFS exercise the put option. CSL said it took this action in response to the publication of a public report by Hindenburg Research, which was going to (and did) destroy YRIV’s share price.

During the relevant period, including when FDL demanded the return of the shares, YRIV’s share price was around US$11.50. After publication of the Hindenburg Report, YRIV’s share price collapsed. By the time of trial, the shares were worthless.

FDL brought proceedings against CSL for (amongst other things) breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, conversion and unjust enrichment. FDL succeeded in its claims, including its claim that CSL had unlawfully retained the YRIV shares following FDL’s demand for their return.[1] Justice Kawaley held that CSL should have returned 50% of the shares, as they were not needed to secure the obligations under the put option. The judgment on liability was handed down on 17 August 2023.

Decision

On 31 January 2024, the Court delivered a ruling on the measure of contractual damages applicable in the case. The primary issues in dispute were (i) what is the ordinary measure of damages in a temporary deprivation of property case, and (ii) in what circumstances should the ordinary measure be displaced?

FDL argued that the ordinary measure of damages was the market price of the shares at the time of the breach less the contract price. Conversely, CSL argued that the ordinary measure did not apply at all to cases of temporary deprivation.[2] Alternatively, CSL argued that it was not appropriate to apply the ordinary measure in the current factual context because FDL would not have, and/or could not have, sold the shares had they been returned.

Legal Principles

The Court held as follows:

  1. In temporary deprivation of property cases in breach of contract, damages will ordinarily be measured by reference to the difference (if any) between the market value of the property when the breach of contract or duty occurs, and the market value when it is recovered.[3]
  2. The plaintiff does not need to prove that it would have sold the property if it had been lawfully returned.
  3. The ordinary rule is not universal. It may be displaced where its underpinning logic is not engaged, such as in circumstances where  the owner could not have, even if they wished, liquidated the property at the prevailing market price upon its return.
  4.  The onus is on the defendant to put the plaintiff to strict proof of its loss. However, even if the defendant does not do so, it may be clear from the evidence that the ordinary rule cannot sensibly be applied.
  5. In assessing damages where the ordinary rule is displaced, the Court must make an estimate as to what the chances are that a particular thing would have happened, and reflect those chances in the amount of damages awarded. For example, the Court may reduce the award which would otherwise have been made on a ‘pure’ market price basis, where this reflects more accurately the true market value.

Decision on the Facts

On the facts, CSL had not pleaded nor adduced evidence at trial that FDL would not or could not have sold the shares had they been returned. FDL therefore was not required to respond to the issue with positive evidence of its own.

However, evidence had been given at trial that (i) it was generally difficult to sell a large block of thinly-traded shares at one time without having a negative impact on the YRIV share price; and (ii) FDL had sought to limit the size of shares available in the market based on concerns about short-selling. In light of these considerations, the Court held that the ordinary rule should be displaced to do justice. Accordingly, the Court applied a 50% discount to the YRIV share price as at 26 October 2018 (when the relevant demand was made) to take into account the “real world value” of the shares. FDL was therefore awarded 50% of the total claimed (US$16.1 million reduced from US$32.2 million). The Court emphasised that the reduction was necessary to reflect the real market value of the shares, as opposed to reflecting that FDL had not proven actual loss (because it would not, and/or could not, have sold the shares).

Comment

  1. The case helpfully provides guidance on the measure of damages in temporary deprivation of property cases. The ordinary rule is that damages will generally be measured by reference to the difference (if any) between the market value of the property, when the breach of contract or duty occurs, and the market value when it is recovered.
  2. The ordinary rule is intended to provide parties with certainty in these types of cases. The market price at the date of wrongful retention and the date of return, in temporary deprivation cases, are rational reference points for ascertaining the quantum of any loss. In applying a sensible and principled approach, commercial actors and litigants should be able to work out more easily where they stand in these types of disputes.
  3. While the ordinary rule will be the starting point in most cases, the case illustrates that it is not a strict rule and there will be circumstances, such as this case, where the rule will be displaced. This is appropriate because there are likely to be many temporary deprivation of property scenarios where it is appropriate to reduce the damages awarded to a plaintiff – for example, where the plaintiff never intended to sell the unlawfully detained property.
  4. The decision highlights the importance of properly preparing and pleading your case from the outset. Cases of temporary deprivation of property will often turn on the counter-factual, which can be difficult for a plaintiff to make out. Had CSL put FDL to strict proof that it would not, and/or could not, have sold the YRIV shares had they been returned, it arguably may have avoided liability altogether.

[1] Whether the put option was waived is currently being litigated before the Nevada Court. If the option is held in those proceedings to have been waived, the Grand Court judgment on liability provides that all YRIV shares should have been returned by CSL on demand by FDL.
[2] This position was developed by CSL in written submissions filed after the hearing. The Court noted that during oral argument CSL had taken a different position – and had not appeared to dispute FDL’s position on the ordinary measure but instead took issue with its application on the facts of this case.
[3] In making this determination, the Court regarded as binding or highly persuasive the Privy Council decision of Solloway v McLaughlin [1938] AC 247, and declined to follow the English Court of Appeal decision of Brandeis Goldschmidt & Co Limited v Western Transport Limited [1981] QB 864.

Key Contacts
Share
More publications
Appleby-Website-Funds-and-Investment-Services
28 Oct 2026

Side Letters: Preferential Terms, Practical Challenges

Side letters are a common feature of Cayman Islands investment funds. This article outlines the legal framework governing side letters, the key considerations for fund operators when negotiating and granting preferential terms, and the implications of side letters for subscription financing arrangements.

Appleby-Website-Arbitration-and-Dispute-Resolution
22 Oct 2026

Grand Court Sees Through "Specific Performance" Label And Stays Redemption Claim In Favour Of HKIAC Arbitration

We are pleased to report on our recent win in the Cayman Grand Court: a stay of Cayman proceedings concerning a US$87m+ redemption claim in favour of HKIAC arbitration. Doyle J found that the claim for "specific performance" was "entirely artificial and a mere device" intended to escape the arbitration clause. The Appleby team comprised John McCarroll SC, Damon Booth and Ray Leung (Hong Kong), and Andrew Jackson and Zuhair Farouki (Cayman). Andrew Ayres KC appeared as leading counsel.

Appleby-Website-Cayman1
21 Oct 2026

The Cayman Islands LLC at ten: what fund finance has learned

Ten years on, the Cayman Islands LLC is an established part of fund finance practice. A useful question is how an LLC’s contractual flexibility affects lender diligence, security and enforcement, and when an exempted company remains the more efficient financing vehicle.

Website-Code-Cayman-1
1 Sep 2026

The Executor's Year in the Law of the Cayman Islands

Of Jarndyce and Jarndyce, the suit which stands at the centre of Bleak House and which concerned an estate drawn into the administration of the Court of Chancery, Dickens wrote that 'this scarecrow of a suit has, in course of time, become so complicated that no man alive knows what it means'. The complaint was not the novelist's invention. It was directed at a state of affairs in which the beneficiary dissatisfied with the conduct of an administration had in substance one remedy, a decree for general administration, which took the whole estate into the hands of the court and kept it there, upon occasion until there was little left to distribute.

Appleby-Website-Corporate-Practice
26 Aug 2026

Comparative Analysis of Cayman and BVI Companies as Listing Vehicles

This article provides an in-depth company-law comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of Cayman Islands and BVI companies as listing vehicles, with a view to assisting businesses in selecting the appropriate jurisdiction of incorporation for their listing vehicle.

Appleby-Website-Insolvency-and-Restructuring
13 Aug 2026

Restructurings Frustrating Creditors And The Enforcement Of Arbitral Awards: The English High Court's Decision In State Oil Company Of Azerbaijan v Mansimov

The English High Court has issued a significant judgment on the enforcement of arbitral awards, the reach of section 423 of the Insolvency Act 1986 and the limits of the Marex tort, with potential relevance to the Cayman Islands' Fraudulent Dispositions Act.

Appleby-Website-Regulatory-Practice
7 Aug 2026

New CIMA Rules on AML/CFT/CPF Compliance and Financial Sanctions Issued in the Cayman Islands

On 20 July 2026, further to an industry consultation, the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA) published the following two new Rules set to introduce binding risk management, governance, sanctions screening and other compliance requirements for regulated financial service providers in the Cayman Islands: (i) Rule on Effective Compliance Programmes for the Prevention and Detection of Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Proliferation Financing for Financial Services Providers (AML Rule); and (ii) Rule on Compliance with Financial Sanctions and Targeted Financial Sanctions (Sanctions Rule and, together with the AML Rule, the Rules). All CIMA-regulated financial services providers, including investment funds, insurers and reinsurers that are conducting ‘relevant financial business’ as defined under the Proceeds of Crime Act (Revised) (POCA) (FSP), are encouraged to review and update their documented framework of AML/CFT/CPF and sanctions compliance policies, procedures, controls, oversight and reporting mechanisms (Compliance Programmes) to ensure compliance with the Rules by the time they come into force on 18 September 2026.

JPLs, Directors and Arbitration: Grand Court Clarifies the Scope of Provisional Liquidators' Powers
5 Aug 2026

Good faith in action, not just belief: the UK Supreme Court’s decision in Saxon Woods Investments Limited v Costa and its significance in the Cayman Islands

May a company director depart from a strategy his board has agreed, in the sincere belief that he knows a better route to the company’s success? In Saxon Woods Investments Limited v Costa [2026] UKSC 21, the Supreme Court held that, whatever the answer, a director cannot pursue his own strategy by concealing it from, and misleading, his fellow directors. The Court confirmed that the good faith duty is not confined to a director’s sincerely held view of the company’s best interests; it also governs the means by which the director acts. The decision is an authoritative statement of the content of the fiduciary duty of loyalty, and is likely to be influential in the Cayman Islands. The decision will interest directors, those who advise or appoint them, and stakeholders affected by directors’ conduct.

Website-Code-Cayman-2
30 Jul 2026

Contingent Creditors, Standing And The Winding Up Jurisdiction: Analysing Re Petrosaudi International

The Cayman Islands Court of Appeal has delivered a highly significant judgment in Re PetroSaudi International.[1] The Court clarified the circumstances in which an alleged contingent creditor will have standing to petition to wind up a company under section 94(1)(b) of the Companies Act, and confirmed that there is no jurisdiction to make a winding up order on an ex parte without notice basis.[2] Our article analyses the Court of Appeal’s decision, and considers its implications for insolvency practitioners.

Website-Code-Cayman-1
30 Jul 2026

Final Means Final: Wei v Wang and the Common Law Enforcement of Foreign Judgments in the Cayman Islands

English Court Reaffirms Pro-Enforcement Approach to Foreign Judgments In Wei v Wang [2026] EWHC 1892 (Comm), the Court confirmed that exceptional avenues of review do not undermine the finality of a judgment and reiterated the limited scope of the natural justice defence.