The case in question centres upon the high-profile divorce case of Michael and Yasmin Prest and has been described by one of the appeal judges as “truly extraordinary”. Mr Prest, a Nigerian born oil tycoon based in Britain and founder of energy company Petrodel resources, separated from his wife of 15 years. In the subsequent divorce proceedings in the High Court, he sought to argue that Petrodel’s assets did not belong to him but were held on trust for his birth family because his father had provided the initial capital, or seed money, subject to that trust.

His evidence was found to be “deceitful and shambolic” and such manoeuvres were trenchantly dismissed. Mr Justice Moylan at first instance concluded that the whole structure was for Mr Prest’s benefit alone and in his control and he was able to change the structure and distribute the wealth within it as he wished; “Petrodel is Mr Prest and Mr Prest is Petrodel”. Drawing adverse inferences against Mr Prest, the judge concluded that he was worth £37.5 million and awarded his wife £17.5 million.

Relying upon the powers conferred by s.24(1)(a) Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 which provides for the transfer or settlement property by one spouse to another to which the spouse is “entitled either in possession or reversion”, Mr Justice Moylan concluded that the “corporate structure was used as a repository for the family wealth” and therefore there existed “no legal impediment to his procuring the transfer of assets held by the companies in his name” as they were his “alter ego”.

A fundamental principle of company law confers a separate legal personality upon a corporate structure and considers its assets to belong beneficially to the company itself and not its shareholders…

Type

Insight

Locations

Jersey

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
5 Jan 2022 |

Trustee Knowledge Series: Advanced Paper Six: Overview of protectors 'ad serviendum ac protegendum”

Appleby Private Client & Trust Partner David Dorgan has authored and distributed a series of Tru...

25 Nov 2021 |

Regulatory Approach to ESG across the Crown Dependencies

New requirements may require investment products to display a label reflecting their sustainability ...

24 Nov 2021 |

'Jersey's Relationship with India: Political, Commercial and Cultural Connections'

Jersey First for Finance has recently published a guide entitled ‘Jersey’s relationship with Ind...

18 Nov 2021 |

Trustee Knowledge Series: Advanced Paper Five - Trusts with Reserved Powers

Appleby Private Client & Trust Partner David Dorgan has authored and distributed a series of Tru...

11 Oct 2021 |

Trustee Knowledge Series: Advanced Paper Four: The proper law and place of administration of trusts and courts with exclusive jurisdiction

Over the next twelve months, Appleby Private Client & Trust Partner David Dorgan will author and...

7 Oct 2021 |

Jersey: an evolving global platform: Jersey First for Finance 2021

This article, taken from Jersey ~ First for Finance ‒ Celebrating 60 Years of Finance 1961-2021 wa...

4 Oct 2021 |

Navigating the Jersey M&A landscape (2 of 3)

This is the second of a series of three articles, each dealing with topics to be considered when buy...

Contributors: Andrew Weaver
22 Sep 2021 |

Minute Writing Training

Trustees are under a statutory duty to keep accurate records of their trusteeship, but what does tha...

15 Sep 2021 |

Navigating the Jersey M&A landscape

This is the first of a series of three articles, each dealing with topics to be considered when buyi...

Contributors: Andrew Weaver
2 Sep 2021 |

Duties of Trustees

The relationship of trustees to beneficiaries is viewed as fiduciary, meaning there are certain equi...