Brexit and Cross Border Insolvencies

It is clear that there will be a need for legislative certainty post Brexit, once the reciprocal recognition of proceedings and determination of member states’ jurisdiction via the EC Regulation on Insolvency Proceedings is lost. The UK Withdrawal Bill currently removes the mechanism of reciprocal recognition and it is yet unclear whether or not UNCITRAL and/or domestic legislation would be relied upon post Brexit, or whether the more legislative certainty via, for example, bilateral treaties, will be available going forwards. Without such treaties in place it is feared that the economy on both sides of the Channel could suffer, particularly if this affects lender confidence as to what may happen in the event of an insolvency.


In a year where we have seen retail, the casual dining sector and construction industries suffer significant distress, the spotlight shone on the charities sector as the latest sector “stretched to breaking point”. Where the Charity Commission in the UK are supervising in excess of 167,000 registered charities in England and Wales, it is thought the primary regulator of this sector is significantly under resourced. In addition, research has shown that more than a quarter of registered charities operate within their reserve of less than 3 months, meaning they are significantly exposed to market fluctuations. It is possible that, in light of the new powers of the Charity Commission being able to wind up charities, without having to request that this is undertaken by the trustees of such charities, this could potentially create new restructuring opportunities.

Lessons from Carillion

From what was easily the biggest insolvency of 2018 (to date), it was fascinating to hear from those on the front line of the collapse of Carillion. The primary messages that were taken away from this historic insolvency were considered to be as follows:

Management culture and transparency – as had been widely publicised, management focus was kept on winning new contracts to ensure cashflow to service existing contracts, whilst the quality of performance of existing contracts suffered. In addition, notwithstanding significant profit warnings, management did not consider there to be any liquidity issues.

There needs to be an interrogation of true debt levels and whether particular types of finance should fall within “supplier finance” or be accounted for differently.

Documentation is key and the usefulness of security reviews cannot be over stated. In Carillion, one of the primary lenders found itself secured against topco only (none of the operating companies) and in a subordinated position behind the pension. Further, despite the eye watering profit warnings, the documentation in place did not expose a covenant breach at this time. A review of facilities and security could have identified and potentially remedied these issues.

Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
20 Jul 2020 |

Listing quoted Eurobonds on The International Stock Exchange

The International Stock Exchange (TISE or the Exchange) provides recognised facilities for the listi...

Contributors: Chris Smedley
23 Jun 2020 |

The International Stock Exchange – The home of UK Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)?

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) were introduced in the UK under the Finance Act 2006 on 1 Janu...

Contributors: Chris Smedley
19 Jun 2020 |

Warranty Claims: On time, but too late?

A recent decision in the English High Court highlighted the importance of buyers acting quickly if t...

3 Jun 2020 |

Appleby’s overview of the key benefits of listing high yield bonds on TISE

In the last few years, an increasing number of issuers of high yield bonds have chosen The Internati...

Contributors: Chris Smedley
31 Jan 2020 |

Brexit Day has arrived: What does that mean for Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man?

Brexit Day has arrived, and at 11 o’clock this evening the UK’s EU membership will come to an en...

9 Oct 2019 |

Transparency and the Crown Dependencies

Transparency of beneficial ownership information has been a political issue since June 2013 when Bri...

18 Sep 2019 |

Offshore listing Vehicles to benefit from the Shanghai - London stock connect

Offshore listing Vehicles to benefit from the Shanghai - London stock connect

26 Jun 2019 |

Regulatory Headwinds

Faced with increased scrutiny from regulators on both global and jurisdictional levels, businesses m...

Contributors: David Dorgan
19 Jun 2019 |

Beneficial Ownership Update: Crown Dependencies

The Crown Dependencies (Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man) have announced a joint policy commitme...

Contributors: Caren Pegg