Examples include prohibitions on an employee working for a competitor (a ‘non-compete’ clause), soliciting or providing services to their former employer’s clients (‘non-solicit’ and ‘non-deal’), or employing their former employer’s staff (‘non-poach’).

The enforceability of restrictive covenants is governed by the common law.  There have been very few relevant cases in the Bermuda courts, which are likely to follow English law.  In England, the standard position is that a restrictive covenant will be void for being in restraint of trade, unless the employer has a legitimate proprietary interest to protect and the scope of the covenant is no more than is reasonable to protect that interest.

This general position applies to all forms of post-termination restriction, but it is most difficult to justify a non-compete, as it effectively prevents an employee from pursuing their livelihood.  In assessing the reasonableness of a non-compete restriction, a court will consider whether some lesser form of protection, such as a non-solicit covenant or a confidentiality clause, would give adequate protection.  The employer would need to make a compelling case that a non-compete is necessary, for example due to the employee’s access to highly-confidential or sensitive information, or their centrality to client relationships.

Some employers will choose to pay the employee during their non-compete period (this is quite common in the United States), but this fact alone is unlikely to mean that a court will enforce a restriction which it considers to be too broad.

Reasonableness is assessed at the time the contract is entered into, so a restriction that would be reasonable for a senior executive could be struck down if it was entered into when the executive was in a junior role which did not justify such an onerous restriction.  For this reason, it is important to keep contractual restrictions under review at appropriate points, for example when an employee is promoted.

In general, a court will not re-write a restriction that it considers too broad.  So, if a court considers that a 6 month non-compete is too long, it will strike the clause out rather than reducing the duration to that which it finds reasonable.  Restrictions therefore require close consideration and careful drafting.

In relation to duration, the employer would need to be able to demonstrate why the length of the restriction, rather than some lesser period, is necessary.  Its reasoning could, for instance, be linked to the ‘shelf-life’ of the confidential information to which the employee has access, or the regularity with which the employee interacts with clients.

Reasonableness is assessed not just by the duration of the restriction but by its overall scope; it may be the case that a well-drafted restriction of a longer duration is more likely to be upheld than a poorly-drafted restriction of a shorter duration.

Leaving aside duration, there are a number of other grounds on which courts commonly strike down covenants, which include:

  • The scope of the business which the employee is prevented from operating in is not limited to only those parts of the former employer’s business in which the employee has been materially involved or had access to confidential information;
  • The customers which the employee is prevented from soliciting or dealing with are not limited only to those with whom he/she personally had material dealings;
  • The staff members which the employee is prevented from poaching are not limited only to those for whom he/she had line management responsibility, or include staff in entry-level or administrative positions;
  • The employee is prevented from working in a geographical area in which his/her former employer does not actually compete;
  • The duration of the restriction is not reduced by any period of time the employee spends on ‘garden leave’.

These are issues which an employer should be mindful of when drafting restrictive covenants in employment contracts.

While employers should ensure that they have well-drafted templates, it is important to consider tailoring the templates for each employee they hire.  Of course, restrictive covenants are also a common point of negotiation with potential recruits.

This is a complex area of the law and it is recommended to seek legal advice when drafting contractual restrictions.

Share
X.com LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
ICLG Fintech 21 cover
5 Jun 2025

Digital transformation done right (Bermuda)

As any specialised tech lawyer or technology consultant will tell you, digital transformation projec...

Appleby-Website-Insurance-and-Reinsurance
2 Jun 2025

2025 Global Financial Crisis Stress Test: Bermuda

The Bermuda Monetary Authority (BMA) has recently published instructions for a significant data coll...

050-Insolvency-Restructuring-Grid-Image
30 May 2025

Bankruptcy & Restructuring – To Enforce, or not to Enforce

Bermuda’s flagship restructuring process is the appointment of provisional liquidators, whose powe...

Bermuda-1024x576-1
22 May 2025

Corporate real estate acquisition in Bermuda

Corporate real estate acquisitions in Bermuda are a matter of careful balance. That is because, a...

Appleby-Website-Insurance-and-Reinsurance
22 May 2025

Long-term reinsurance and ILS are set for growth

After a record-breaking  2024, Bermuda’s life reinsurance sector is likely to expand further this...

Appleby-Website-Insurance-and-Reinsurance
15 May 2025

Bermuda: The vital role of the principal representative

Bermuda's regulatory framework requires every insurance company registered under the Insurance Act 1...

Employment-and-Immigration
30 Apr 2025

The End of the Digital Nomad Visa: How Else Can Individuals Reside in Bermuda?

As of 28 February 2025, Bermuda officially discontinued its popular “Work from Bermuda” (WFB) Ce...

Appleby-Website-Private-Client-and-Trusts-Practice
25 Apr 2025

Compliance with Pipa for trustees

The Personal Information Protection Act 2016, the island’s data protection legislation, applies to...

Appleby-Website-Privacy-and-Data-Protection
14 Apr 2025

M&A transactions under PIPA (Bermuda)

Mergers and business acquisitions are among the many different types of business transactions that r...

Appleby-Website-Insurance-and-Reinsurance
1 Apr 2025

Bermuda: With everything growing, all of the ILS world will rise together

It’s been an exceptionally busy and record start to the year for the catastrophe bond sector, and ...