Whilst this was a pragmatic interpretation of Cayman Islands law that resulted in the logical commercial outcome in that particular case (in which there was no shareholder opposition), the ruling in China Milk was criticised for giving directors a wider discretion than was intended by the legislation. In a carefully considered judgment handed down on 25 November 2015, Mrs Justice Mangatal disagreed with Mr Justice Jones’s construction of the statutory provisions and struck out a winding up petition brought by the directors of an insolvent company who did not have the requisite authority from the shareholders to petition for the company’s winding up.

The decision, as has been widely anticipated would occur in an appropriate case, has removed the ability of directors to unilaterally petition for the winding up of an insolvent company in circumstances where the shareholders do not support their proposal. This absence of this alternative will inevitably cause difficulty for directors’ who owe fiduciary duties to the company, and must take into account the needs of creditors in considering these duties, when the company enters the “zone of insolvency”. Directors may then be left in the difficult position of being forced to resign rather than carry on as stewards of an insolvent company without the power to petition the Court to place the company in liquidation. The legislative intent of the relevant Companies Law provision in the Cayman Islands is to permit a winding up of insolvent companies by creditors. This decision highlights that the law as drafted prevents the directors from acting directly in the interests of creditors when the shareholders are apathetic or act in their own self-interests and highlights the need for consideration of further legislative reform.

Read More

Type

Insight

Locations

Cayman Islands

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
1 Jun 2022

The 2022 Cayman Islands Real Estate Guide

The Real Estate 2022 guide provides the latest legal information on the impact of disruptive technol...

Contributors: Norman Klein
28 Apr 2022

Restructuring the offshore debt of Chinese Real Estate Developers

This article sets out how the current regimes in the Cayman Islands and the BVI can assist with rest...

Contributors: Crystal Au-Yeung
28 Apr 2022

Assignment, novation or sub-participation of loans             

Transfers of loan portfolios between lending institutions have always been commonplace in the financ...

26 Jan 2022

Appleby contributes four chapters to Global Legal Insights – Fund Finance 2022: Cayman Islands

2021 has been an incredibly impressive year for the global subscription credit and fund finance mark...

Contributors: Georgina Pullinger
27 Oct 2021

We hope this registers! A summary of Cayman corporate and partnership registers in a finance transaction.

Because we know that it can be a little befuddling, Appleby has set out a guide to the various Cayma...

7 Oct 2021

Regulatory Round-Up: Cayman Islands Q3 2021

Appleby Cayman’s Our latest Regulatory updates for the Cayman Islands up to Q3 2021.

13 Sep 2021

Loans & Secured Financing in the Cayman Islands 2021

First published in Getting the Deal Through 2021. This practice guide provides topical analysis of L...

Contributors: Alexandra Simpson
21 May 2021

2021 - A Jekyll and Hyde Year for SPACs

In this article we offer our views on why this has happened and look ahead to the future for SPACs a...

Contributors: Dean Bennett
13 May 2021

The 2021 Cayman Islands Real Estate Guide

The Real Estate 2021 guide provides the latest legal information on the impact of disruptive technol...

Contributors: Norman Klein
13 May 2021

British Virgin Islands: Mergers & Acquisitions Comparative Guide

This country-specific Q&A provides an overview to Mergers & Acquisitions laws and regulati...

Contributors: Brittany Cummings