While the draft guidance itself is restricted to local industry consultation only, the enhancements made reflect an intelligent and business minded response to industry input so far, and a meaningful commitment to absorbing the new global regime, applicable to all reputable and familiar financial centres, in a sensible and practical way. The guidance provides support for understanding the scope of the economic substance law (ESL), and how to comply with it.

One of the principal revisions to note is the application of the ESL to all “entities” as opposed to “relevant entities” alone, as prescribed in the International Tax Co-operation (Economic Substance) (Amendment) Bill, 2019. In summary, entities are all legal personalities that are registered with the Cayman Islands’ General Registry. A relevant entity is an entity that is not a domestic company, an investment fund or an entity that is tax resident outside of the Cayman Islands. A relevant entity – carrying on a relevant activity – is required to satisfy an economic substance test and is also required to prepare and submit to the Cayman Tax Information Authority a report for the purpose of the Authority’s determination whether the economic substance test has been satisfied. This is an important change and, in anticipation of implementation, many Cayman domiciled entities are currently receiving questionnaires from their Cayman registered office service providers to complete in this respect. All entities are required to notify the Authority annually of, among other things, whether or not they are carrying on a relevant activity and, if so, whether or not they are a relevant entity. The deadline for notification is provisionally slated for March 2020 via an online portal.

To recap, “relevant activity” falls under nine sector headings:

  1. Banking business;
  2. Distribution and service centre business;
  3. Financing and leasing business;
  4. Fund management business;
  5. Headquarters business;
  6. Holding company business;
  7. Insurance business;
  8. Intellectual property business; or
  9. Shipping business;

Investment fund business is not included. Notably, the term investment fund includes the investment fund itself but also any entity through which an investment fund directly or indirectly invests or operates (excepting the entity that is itself the ultimate investment held).

The economic substance test requires that a relevant entity conducting a relevant activity:

  1. Conducts Cayman Islands core income generating activities (CIGA) in relation to that relevant activity varying on a sector basis;
  2. Is directed and managed in an appropriate manner in the Cayman Islands in relation to that relevant activity; and
  3. Having regard to the level of relevant income derived from the relevant activity carried out in the Cayman Islands, has in the Cayman Islands:
  • An adequate amount of operating expenditure incurred;
  • An adequate physical presence (including maintaining a place of business or plant, property and equipment); and
  • An adequate number of full-time employees or other personnel with appropriate qualifications.

The terms relevance, in the contexts of activity, entity and the gross income derived from that activity, appropriateness and adequacy each requires a detailed case-by-case legal analysis of the precise fact pattern within which a Cayman domiciled legal personality operates. If not already in process, Cayman legal advice should be taken without delay to determine whether clients with Cayman touch points are subject to the jurisdictional substance requirements.

While remaining a work in progress, the revised guidance provides detailed and helpful sector specific commentary including illustrative examples with respect to typical scenarios. It is clear that these have been informed by ongoing industry consultation and, while not intended to be binding or definitive, at least provide a general frame of reference within which a considered analysis may be undertaken. This is encouraging insofar as it is a clear indication of the Cayman Islands Government’s, and consequently the Authority’s, commitment to address and implement the ESL collaboratively with industry participants.

Local and verifiable outsourcing is permitted in certain circumstances and a growing number of Cayman service providers are positioning themselves to meet demand. Some relevant entities will already meet ESL requirements with little effort while others will need to undertake a more detailed and substantive review. In short, while common fact patterns will emerge, there will not be a “one-size-fits-all” solution to compliance in any given sector, as will be the case across all offshore financial centres.

Notwithstanding the challenges, for some, that the ESL will present, it remains the case that Cayman, as a tax neutral, internationally recognised and economically stable jurisdiction will maintain its position as an attractive option for international financial planning. This remains particularly the case as US economic growth continues and financial markets remain reasonably priced. With its continued focus on quality, innovation and expertise, it seems reasonable to expect that the “new normal” brought about by economic substance will be absorbed by the market and in no way hinder the Cayman Islands’ continued success.

Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
27 Sep 2022

Similar but Different

While the basic features of the trust remain, there are some notable differences in how trusts can b...

30 Aug 2022

The Cayman Islands restructuring officer regime comes into force on 31 August 2022

These new proceedings will significantly enhance the Cayman Islands restructuring regime.

4 Aug 2022

Norwich Pharmacal orders: the right medicine for third party disclosure of information and documents in the Cayman Islands

A Norwich Pharmacal order (NPO) is a disclosure order available in the Cayman Islands to compel a th...

Contributors: Susan Fallan
1 Jun 2022

The 2022 Cayman Islands Real Estate Guide

The Real Estate 2022 guide provides the latest legal information on the impact of disruptive technol...

Contributors: Norman Klein
28 Apr 2022

Restructuring the offshore debt of Chinese Real Estate Developers

This article sets out how the current regimes in the Cayman Islands and the BVI can assist with rest...

Contributors: Crystal Au-Yeung
28 Apr 2022

Assignment, novation or sub-participation of loans             

Transfers of loan portfolios between lending institutions have always been commonplace in the financ...

26 Jan 2022

Appleby contributes four chapters to Global Legal Insights – Fund Finance 2022: Cayman Islands

2021 has been an incredibly impressive year for the global subscription credit and fund finance mark...

Contributors: Georgina Pullinger
27 Oct 2021

We hope this registers! A summary of Cayman corporate and partnership registers in a finance transaction.

Because we know that it can be a little befuddling, Appleby has set out a guide to the various Cayma...

7 Oct 2021

Regulatory Round-Up: Cayman Islands Q3 2021

Appleby Cayman’s Our latest Regulatory updates for the Cayman Islands up to Q3 2021.

13 Sep 2021

Loans & Secured Financing in the Cayman Islands 2021

First published in Getting the Deal Through 2021. This practice guide provides topical analysis of L...

Contributors: Alexandra Simpson