The recent judgement of His Honour Deemster Doyle in the case of AB v CD highlighted an area of uncertainty in Manx trust law by questioning under what circumstances would the Manx courts be willing to interfere with a trustee’s decision which has given rise to unintended consequences, including unintended tax consequences.

AB v CD

AB v CD concerned an application for an order to set aside a number of call options (Options) granted by the Defendant over the assets of eight discretionary trusts established under Manx law (Trusts). The order was applied for under the rule as established by the case of Hastings-Bass (the Hastings-Bass Rule) (also referred to as the proper deliberation rule) or, in the alternative, on the grounds of mistake. The Claimant was the settlor and primary beneficiary of the Trusts and the Defendant was the trustee.

Type

Insight

Locations

Isle of Man

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
2 Dec 2019 |

The International Comparative Legal Guide to Gambling 2020 – Isle of Man Chapter

Appleby has provided the Isle of Man chapter to the ICLG Gambling 2020. The "International Comparati...

Contributors: Sophie Corkish
2 Dec 2019 |

Reflections on the 16th Annual Isle of Man STEP Conference 2019

Appleby Isle of Man Senior Associate Erin Trimble-Cregeen and Associate Melissa Wong recently attend...

Contributors: Erin Trimble-Cregeen
9 Oct 2019 |

Transparency and the Crown Dependencies

Transparency of beneficial ownership information has been a political issue since June 2013 when Bri...

18 Sep 2019 |

Offshore listing Vehicles to benefit from the Shanghai - London stock connect

Offshore listing Vehicles to benefit from the Shanghai - London stock connect

Contributors: Huiyan Liew
22 Jul 2019 |

Isle of Man Personal Injury Discount Rate Revision

The Lord Chancellor has this week announced the long-awaited revision of the Discount Rate in Englan...

26 Jun 2019 |

Regulatory Headwinds

Faced with increased scrutiny from regulators on both global and jurisdictional levels, businesses m...

Contributors: David Dorgan
24 Jun 2019 |

Reflections on the AIJA – INSOL Europe Joint Insolvency Conference

Claire Corkish attended the AIJA - INSOL Europe Young Members Insolvency Seminar in Mallorca on 13-1...

Contributors: Caren Pegg
19 Jun 2019 |

Beneficial Ownership Update: Crown Dependencies

The Crown Dependencies (Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man) have announced a joint policy commitme...

Contributors: Alison MacKrill, Caren Pegg
11 Jun 2019 |

Appleby champions workplace diversity and boardroom representation with its Female Leaders Network

Appleby announced its Female Leaders Network on International Women’s Day on 8 March 2019, an init...

Contributors: Caren Pegg, Claire Milne WS
31 May 2019 |

GDPR One Year On: End of Transitional Provisions and Likely Future Developments in the Isle of Man

Saturday 25 May marked one year of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) being fully enforce...

Contributors: Claire Milne WS