The recent judgement of His Honour Deemster Doyle in the case of AB v CD highlighted an area of uncertainty in Manx trust law by questioning under what circumstances would the Manx courts be willing to interfere with a trustee’s decision which has given rise to unintended consequences, including unintended tax consequences.

AB v CD

AB v CD concerned an application for an order to set aside a number of call options (Options) granted by the Defendant over the assets of eight discretionary trusts established under Manx law (Trusts). The order was applied for under the rule as established by the case of Hastings-Bass (the Hastings-Bass Rule) (also referred to as the proper deliberation rule) or, in the alternative, on the grounds of mistake. The Claimant was the settlor and primary beneficiary of the Trusts and the Defendant was the trustee.

Type

Insight

Locations

Isle of Man

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
30 Jul 2021 |

Fighting international fraud

First published in New Law Journal, July 2021. Appleby partners Anthony William and Jared Dann an...

Contributors: Jared Dann, Claire Corkish
28 Jul 2021 |

Trust Protectors and the Exercise of Trustee Powers

The recent judgment of the Staff of Government Division in the case of Mazzoleni v Summerhill Trust ...

Contributors: Erin Trimble-Cregeen
18 Jun 2021 |

Isle of Man – Extension of Economic Substance Requirements to Partnerships and Limited Liability Companies

The Income Tax (Substance Requirements) Order 2021 was approved by Tynwald on 16 June 2021.  This O...

12 Mar 2021 |

Material adverse change clauses in light of the Covid-19 pandemic

Experts from each of our key global offices provide jurisdiction specific advice and answer question...

8 Mar 2021 |

Appleby Celebrates International Women’s Day

International Women’s Day is celebrated annually in support of gender equality and equal participa...

8 Dec 2020 |

The International Comparative Legal Guide to Gambling 2021 – Isle of Man Chapter

This chapter was first published in The International Comparative Legal Guide to: Gambling 2021, by ...

Contributors: Sophie Corkish
30 Oct 2020 |

When Worlds Collide – How COVID is Connecting Technology with Natural Resources

Dating back to the beginning of 2020, the natural resources sector has been extremely active at both...

Contributors: Peter Colegate