Disclosure of Trust information by trustees to beneficiaries is fundamental in permitting beneficiaries to assert their right to hold trustees to account in the administration of a trust. In parallel, the EU has decided that disclosure of trust information is crucial in the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing. Therefore, two questions arise about the interaction of the two regimes regarding disclosure of trust information: can a beneficiary still obtain trust information where the trustees have decided not to disclose that information, and perhaps a court has agreed with them? And are trustees required to disclose trust information to non-beneficiaries?

In the UK, a beneficiary could use a subject access request (SAR), pursuant to s7 of the Data Protection Act 1998 (DPA), to obtain disclosure against either the trustee (if resident in the UK) or, more importantly for trustees resident in the Crown Dependencies (CD trustees), legal advisors resident in the UK and holding trust information as part of their instructions. The latter was confirmed by the English Court of Appeal case of Dawson-Damer v Taylor Wessing LLP. This case may have consequences for any non-UK resident trustee who instructs the services of UK lawyers.

CD trustees might instruct UK resident lawyers to advise on, for example, a transaction involving London realty. As part of those instructions, CD trustees are likely to provide the legal advisor with copies of trust documentation, including, perhaps, trustees’ minutes and other information that might not otherwise be disclosable to beneficiaries. Pursuant to the aforementioned case, that trust information held by the legal advisor could be exposed to disclosure pursuant to a SAR.

But hang on – the DPA contains a specific exemption from a SAR for legal advice and proceedings. Although this is true, and was argued by Taylor Wessing in Dawson-Damer, the Court of Appeal held that this exemption should be narrowly construed and applied to documentation that could be withheld as a matter of English law. The trust was governed by Bahamian law and the Court of Appeal rejected the argument that the exemption should extend to restrictions under foreign-law principles. The DPA does not contain an exemption mirroring applicable trust-law principles on disclosure, and the Court of Appeal made it clear that parliament would need to include such an exemption if that was the intention. In this regard, the Court of Appeal knew that the purpose of the SAR was for the beneficiary to obtain information to use in Bahamian litigation against the trustee, but held that this was not a ground to prevent compliance with the SAR. Therefore, a SAR under the DPA can circumvent well-established trust-law principles, including the disclosure of trustees’ deliberations not ordinarily disclosable, if held by the legal advisors. Consequently, ‘fishing’ SARs could be used as a litigation tactic.

To read more, click the link below.

Type

Insight

Sectors

Private Equity

Locations

Jersey

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
1 Aug 2022

Register of Overseas Entities: A Jersey perspective

The Register of Overseas Entities at Companies House (ROE), as contemplated by the Economic Crime (T...

30 Jun 2022

Digital Identification in Jersey

There have been considerable changes made to the way we do business in recent times. These changes w...

Contributors: Gemma Whale, Paul Worsnop
17 Jun 2022

Proposals to amend the Powers of Attorney (Jersey) Law 1995

Following the recent update from our Guernsey colleagues on the introduction of lasting or enduring ...

Contributors: Gemma Whale
9 Jun 2022

Trustee Knowledge Series: Masters Paper Two: Family Governance

Appleby Private Client & Trust Partner David Dorgan has authored and distributed a series of Tru...

17 May 2022

Navigating the Jersey M&A landscape (3 of 3)

This is the third of a series of three articles, each dealing with topics to be considered when buyi...

Contributors: Andrew Weaver
5 May 2022

The Economic Crime (Transparency and Enforcement) Act 2022: a Jersey perspective

The new Economic Crime (Transparency and Enforcement) Act received Royal Assent on 15 March 2022 (th...

Contributors: Andrew Weaver, Gemma Whale
21 Apr 2022

Listing Private Equity Acquisition Debt on The International Stock Exchange

This article provides a summary of Appleby listing agent services in the Channel Islands, and also o...

12 Apr 2022

Trustee Knowledge Series: Masters Paper One: PTC Structures

Appleby Private Client & Trust Partner David Dorgan has authored and distributed a series of Tru...

16 Mar 2022

Trustee Knowledge Series: Advanced Paper Eight: Amending Mistakes

It is almost inevitable that during the life of most trusts (which can now last indefinitely in many...

4 Mar 2022

The International Stock Exchange (TISE) has launched its new bespoke auction trading system, NOVA

Appleby is a leading listing agent with TISE, which listed 1,111 securities during 2021 against the ...