The Cayman Grand Court Rules do not expressly deal with the grant of leave to issue derivative proceedings in other jurisdictions, nor has that question been addressed in any reported decision of the Cayman courts. This recent decision of the New York Appellate Division therefore raises a key question: is it possible to obtain approval from the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands to bring derivative proceedings in New York or any other jurisdiction?

Facts of the case

The Plaintiff, Paul Davis, was a significant minority shareholder of a Cayman-incorporated company, Scottish Re Group Limited (the Company) who brought proceedings in New York against the Company, its US subsidiary, majority shareholders and directors (the Investors). He alleged, amongst other things, that the Investors influenced the Company’s Board of Directors causing the Company to enter into an undervalued cash-out merger and to implement a dividend strategy which unfairly prejudiced the minority shareholders.

The Plaintiff’s claims were initially dismissed for lack of standing and lack of jurisdiction. He appealed and the Appellate Division affirmed that the dispute was governed by the law of the Cayman Islands pursuant to the internal affairs doctrine (which provides that claims concerning the relationship between a company, its directors and a shareholder are governed by the law of the state or country of the company’s incorporation). The Appellate court further affirmed that Order 15 rule 12A of the Cayman Islands Grand Court Rules is a substantive law under the conflict of laws principles and that non-compliance with the rule will result in dismissal of the derivative action for lack of standing.

Read More

Type

Insight

Locations

Cayman Islands

Share
Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
13 Sep 2021 |

Loans & Secured Financing in the Cayman Islands 2021

First published in Getting the Deal Through 2021. This practice guide provides topical analysis of L...

Contributors: Alexandra Simpson
21 May 2021 |

2021 - A Jekyll and Hyde Year for SPACs

In this article we offer our views on why this has happened and look ahead to the future for SPACs a...

Contributors: Dean Bennett
13 May 2021 |

The 2021 Cayman Islands Real Estate Guide

The Real Estate 2021 guide provides the latest legal information on the impact of disruptive technol...

Contributors: Norman Klein
13 May 2021 |

British Virgin Islands: Mergers & Acquisitions Comparative Guide

This country-specific Q&A provides an overview to Mergers & Acquisitions laws and regulati...

Contributors: Brittany Cummings
13 May 2021 |

Cayman Islands: Mergers & Acquisitions Comparative Guide

This country-specific Q&A provides an overview to Mergers & Acquisitions laws and regulati...

Contributors: Dean Bennett, Vance Power
15 Apr 2021 |

6 months on: Temporary relocation and residency by investment continues to increase in popularity

Six months on from the new digital nomad programmes, did the predicted upward trend reflect the real...

25 Mar 2021 |

Full Steam Ahead at the Jersey Ships Registry

Against a backdrop of uncertainty surrounding Brexit and the difficulties created by the global pand...

24 Mar 2021 |

Economic Substance update Q1 2021

Economic Substance update Q1 2021

12 Mar 2021 |

Material adverse change clauses in light of the Covid-19 pandemic

Experts from each of our key global offices provide jurisdiction specific advice and answer question...