I. Introduction

The necessary reliance on local courts for enforcement of foreign arbitral awards can lead to significant delays in finalising a dispute. Obtaining a favorable arbitration award is often only half the battle, as subsequent annulment and enforcement proceedings can last years. A particularly common problemis the staying of an enforcement award pending determination of annulment proceedings in the seat of the arbitration. The years it takes for a final determination of these post-award proceedings renders nugatory any favorable award, and places in jeopardy the value and competence of international arbitration in resolving commercial disputes.

Until recently, courts have shown considerable reluctance to enforce arbitral awards that are subject to annulment proceedings. Such reluctance is understandable, especially in light of the principles underpinning the New York Convention on the Reciprocal Enforcement of Arbitration Awards 1958 (Convention) and the comity between courts of signatory parties. The Bermuda Court of Appeal considered these principles recently in the decision of LAEP Investments Ltd v Emerging Markets Special Situations 3 Ltd, [2015] CA (BDA) 10 Civ, 9 (LAEP case). Whilst sympathetic to the enforcing party’s situation, the court ultimately found that even a potential delay of 10 or more years occasioned by the annulment proceedings in Brazilian courts to be insufficient to allow prior enforcement.

Read More





Twitter LinkedIn Email Save as PDF
More Publications
29 Jun 2022

Bermuda’s legal system

Through an elected Bar Council, the Bar Association — in conjunction with the Supreme Court Judici...

29 Jun 2022

Avoid These 3 Common NDA Drafting Mistakes

It is difficult to think of a transaction that doesn’t begin with a confidentiality or non-disclos...

28 Jun 2022

Bermuda: a restructuring destination

Bermuda has an outsized, first-class insurance and financial sector, attracting complex, multination...

Contributors: James Batten
27 Jun 2022

Insurtech ILS and the New Normal

As Bermuda and the global markets with which the Island transacts move towards the so-called  ‘ne...

Contributors: Josephine Noddings
23 Jun 2022

Digital Assets in a Crypto Winter

In 2013, IT engineer James Howells was cleaning out his house. He had two identical hard drives: one...

Contributors: James Batten
22 Jun 2022

Bloomberg Tax Country Guide: Bermuda

Bloomberg Tax Country Guides provide overviews of the tax regimes of more than 200 jurisdictions. Th...

Contributors: Ashley Bento
9 Jun 2022

Bermuda’s long-term re/insurance landscape

Bermuda’s long-term re/insurance market has grown considerably in recent years. The island now has...

2 Jun 2022

Provisional Liquidation In Bermuda

Provisional liquidation in Bermuda is a distinctive, flexible regime that operates to support compan...

Contributors: James Batten
23 May 2022

The good life: Bermuda’s new economic pillar

The life sector has moved swiftly from being a new ‘nice-to-have’ in the Bermuda marketplace, to...

5 May 2022

Restructuring of (Re) Insurers during Covid-19

Restructuring involves changing the financial, operational, legal or other structures of a business ...